跳至主要內容
引 AMCM 指引通 GUIDELINES HUB
銀行業 資本充足 僅英文/葡文 HTML 全文

監督檢查程序指引

文號 第015/B/2022-DSB/AMCM號傳閱文件 文號年份 2022 官方來源 AMCM 指引頁 最近核實 2026-11-21
本指引目前僅有英文官方版本,以下為英文原文全文(由官方 PDF 提取)。中文參考譯本製作中,發布後將在此頁提供。如與官方原文有差異,以官方公布版本為準。

Circular No. 015/B/2022-DSB/AMCM(Effective Date: 28/11/2022)

GUIDELINE ON SUPERVISORY REVIEW PROCESS

The Monetary Authority of Macao (AMCM), under the powers conferred by Article 9 of theCharter approved by Decree-Law No.14/96/M of 11th March and by Article 6 of the FinancialSystem Act of Macao (FSAM) approved by Decree-Law No.32/93/M of 5th July, establishesthe following:

INTRODUCTION

1. The Pillar 2 Supervisory Review Process (SRP) is an integral and important part of theBasel II Regulatory Capital Framework (Basel II). It is intended not only to ensure thatbanks should have adequate capital to support all the risks in their business, but also toencourage banks to develop and use better risk management techniques in monitoringand managing their risks.

2. The SRP comprises two main components, the Internal Capital Adequacy AssessmentProcess (ICAAP) and the Supervisory Review and Evaluation Process (SREP).

(a) Under the ICAAP, the management of a bank should develop its own ICAAPand set capital targets that are commensurate with the bank’s risk profile andcontrol environment. The management of a bank bears the responsibility forensuring that the bank has adequate capital to support its risks beyond theregulatory capital requirement.

(b) Under the SREP, the AMCM will review and evaluate how well a bank assessits capital needs relative to its risks and take measures, where appropriate. It isintended to generate an active dialogue between a bank and the AMCM so thatwhen excessive risks, insufficient capital or deficiencies are identified, promptand decisive actions can be taken to reduce risks, address deficiencies or restorecapital.

Purpose

3. The purpose of this Guideline1 is to describe the specific elements that the AMCMrequires a bank’s ICAAP to encompass. It also provides a transparent and informativedescription of the methodology and the supervisory procedures that the AMCM willadopt for capital assessment of banks, and that will be integrated into a risk-basedsupervision framework.

1 The guideline should be read in conjunction with other guidelines issued by the AMCM that are relevant to theassessment of a bank’s risks and capital adequacy.

Page 1 of 26

4. This Guideline follows a principle-based approach with a focus on selected key aspectsfrom a supervisory perspective. The implementation of an ICAAP that is adequate fora bank’s particular circumstances remains the responsibility of the bank. The AMCMassesses a bank’s ICAAP on a case-by-case basis.

Scope of Application

5. The requirements set out in this Guideline fully apply to all banks incorporated inMacao on both a solo and a consolidated basis.

6. The requirements of the ICAAP are not applicable to branches of overseas incorporatedbanks in Macao, but the AMCM may refer to the home supervisor’s consolidatedassessment of the ICAAP of the head office when necessary. The AMCM will also takeinto account the strength and availability of the support from the head office.

Structure of the Guideline

7. There are three sections in this Guideline:

Section I sets out the principles and arrangements of the SRP;Section II describes the general requirements and elements that should be included inthe ICAAP; andSection III defines the principles and methodologies of the SREP.

SECTION I – PRINCIPLES AND ARRANGEMENTS OF THE SRP

Principles of the SRP

8. The AMCM’s approach to the SRP is underpinned by the following four key principles:

Principle 1: Banks should have a process for assessing their overall capitaladequacy in relation to their risk profile and a strategy for maintainingtheir capital level.

Principle 2: The AMCM has the responsibility and power to review and evaluatebanks’ internal capital adequacy assessments and strategies, as wellas their ability to monitor and ensure their compliance with regulatorycapital ratios. The AMCM will take appropriate supervisory action ifthey are not satisfied with the result of this process.

Principle 3: The AMCM expects banks to operate above the minimum regulatorycapital ratios under Pillar 1 and has the ability to require banks to holdcapital in excess of the minimum.

Page 2 of 26

Principle 4: The AMCM will seek to intervene at an early stage to prevent capitalfrom falling below the minimum levels required to support the riskcharacteristics of a particular bank and will require rapid remedialaction if capital is not maintained or restored.

Proportionality

9. The concept of proportionality is key to the SRP, including the ICAAP and the SREP.The ICAAP should be commensurate and proportionate to the nature, scale andcomplexity of the activities of each bank. Similarly, the depth, frequency and intensityof the SREP will be determined by the risks posed to the AMCM’s supervisoryobjectives.

Supervisory Arrangements

10. The SRP will be conducted as part of the AMCM’s risk-based supervision and in linewith the proportionality concept described above, covering the significant businessactivities of a bank on a solo and a consolidated basis.

11. For a bank which has overseas branches and/or subsidiaries, the AMCM as homesupervisor of the bank may seek comments from relevant host supervisors on thefinancial and operating soundness of those branches or subsidiaries in their jurisdictionsin the course of conducting the SRP on a consolidated basis when necessary.

12. For a bank which is a subsidiary of a foreign bank group, the AMCM will consider thestrength and availability of parental support as well as other relevant information fromthe home supervisor of the group when conducting the SRP.

13. For branches of overseas incorporated banks in Macao, the AMCM will also assess thestrength and availability of the support from head office. When necessary, the AMCMmay discuss the ICAAP and the SREP with the home supervisor of the foreign bankgroup to ensure the soundness of the group on a consolidated basis.

SECTION II - THE ICAAP

Overview of the ICAAP

14. As a core component of Pillar 2, the ICAAP is a set of activities and processes whichinvolve ongoing assessment of a bank’s risks, how the bank intends to mitigate thoserisks and how much current and future capital is necessary having considered its riskprofile. For detailed requirements regarding the determination of the internal capitalrequirement, please refer to paragraphs 52-54.

Page 3 of 26

15. Under the ICAAP, a bank should carry out internal capital adequacy assessment basedon its risk assessment results of the last financial year2. A capital planning with stresstesting should also be conducted, covering a period of at least three years following thelast financial year. The above results should be presented in a report (i.e. ICAAP report)and submitted to the AMCM not later than 30th April of each year following the lastfinancial year. For detailed requirements regarding the ICAAP report, please refer toparagraphs 55-58.

16. A bank should implement its ICAAP based on the detailed requirements set out in thefollowing paragraphs of this Guideline. Key aspects for the ICAAP implementationhave been set out in Annex 1 for reference.

General Requirements

17. A bank has the primary responsibility for defining and developing its ICAAP. It shouldbe able to demonstrate to the AMCM that its ICAAP is in place and comprehensive forassessing its overall capital adequacy in relation to its risk profile and there is a strategyfor maintaining its adequate capital levels. Its chosen internal capital targets should bewell founded and consistent with its overall risk profile and current operatingenvironment.

18. A bank should ensure the outcome of its ICAAP is not a static capital target. Thefollowing aspects should also be taken into account in the ICAAP of a bank:

(a) The ICAAP should take into account the current stage of the business cycle ofa bank and be a forward-looking process capable of timely response to changesin the risk profile and business strategies of a bank, as well as its externalenvironment;

(b) The ICAAP should address both short and long-term needs and consider theprudence of building excess capital over benign periods of the credit cycle andalso to withstand a severe and prolonged market downturn;

(c) The ICAAP should incorporate rigorous stress testing where possible events orchanges in market conditions that could adversely impact the bank wereidentified. The ICAAP should incorporate the results of these stress tests, whereapplicable.

19. A bank should implement its ICAAP in a methodical manner and ensure that theICAAP is comprehensively documented in its policies, processes and procedures.

20. The ICAAP should be integrated in the management and decision-making processes ofa bank and duly communicated throughout the bank.

2 Refers to the financial year before the year of ICAAP report submission hereinafter mentioned.

Page 4 of 26

21. A bank should plan and implement regular (at least annual) and robust review of itsICAAP by appropriately qualified persons who are operationally independent of theconduct of capital management.

22. The extent of formalization and sophistication of the ICAAP of each bank may varyaccording to the nature, scale and complexity of the activities of each bank. At aminimum, a bank should have the following key elements in its ICAAP:

(a) Board and senior management oversight;

(b) Sound capital assessment;

(c) Comprehensive assessment of risks ;

(d) Monitoring and reporting; and

(e) Internal control review.

Board and Senior Management Oversight

23. The board and senior management of a bank should recognize that a sound riskmanagement process is the foundation for an effective assessment of the adequacy of abank’s capital position. They should view capital planning as a crucial element in abank’s ability to achieve its desired strategic objectives.

24. The board and senior management of a bank should have sufficient knowledge,experience and background to ensure that adequate policies and procedures, internalcontrol and risk monitoring systems are in place.

25. The board of a bank should define the bank’s risk appetite and establish an acceptablerisk tolerance level while senior management should understand the nature and level ofrisk being undertaken by the bank and how this relates to adequate capital levels. Theboard should also ensure that senior management performs the followingresponsibilities:

(a) Performing an analysis of the current and future capital requirements of the bankin relation to its strategic objectives;

(b) Establishing a strategic plan which clearly outlines the bank’s capital needs,anticipated capital expenditures, desired capital levels, and external capitalsources;

(c) Establishing frameworks for assessing the various risks facing the bank;

Page 5 of 26

(d) Developing a system to relate risks to the capital level of the bank as part of itsinternal assessment of capital adequacy;

(e) Establishing detailed policies that set specific institution-wide controls on thebank’s activities, which are consistent with its risk appetite and capacity;

(f) Developing and communicating strong internal controls and written policiesand procedures for capital planning and assessment throughout the bank; and

(g) Establishing methods for monitoring compliance with regulatory capitalstandards and internal policies.

26. The board of a bank should at least annually review and approve the target levels andcomposition of capital, and the process for setting and monitoring such targets, toensure congruence between the risk profile and capital adequacy of the bank. Seniormanagement should also ensure a comprehensive ICAAP review is conducted at leastannually (or more frequently as deemed necessary), to ascertain the ICAAP remainsappropriate and effective.

Sound Capital Assessment

27. A sound capital assessment should include the following fundamental elements:

(a) Policies and procedures designed to ensure that the bank identifies, measures,and reports all material risks;

(b) A process reflecting the nature, scale and complexity of the activities of the bankthat relates capital to the level of risk in accordance with the risk tolerance levelapproved by the board;

(c) A process that states the bank’s capital adequacy goals with respect to risks,taking account of the bank’s strategic focus and business plan; and

(d) A process of internal control, review and audit to ensure the integrity of theoverall management process.

28. Based on those material risks identified, a bank should assess both short-term and long-term capital requirements, and further develop its capital plan to ensure capital stability.

29. A bank’s capital objective should go beyond the regulatory capital requirement andensure that it has adequate capital to cover all material risks to which it is exposed. Abank should set both a consolidated capital target level and a solo capital target levelfor each of its subsidiaries if any through capital planning which should cover a periodof at least three years following the last financial year.

Page 6 of 26

30. A bank’s capital planning should be established for both normal conditions (ordinaryplanning) and stress conditions (stress planning) based on the year-end figures of thelast financial year, factoring in the potential difficulties of raising additional capitalduring downturns or other times of stress.

Comprehensive Assessment of Risks

31. A bank should ensure that its ICAAP addresses all material risks faced by the bank asthey relate to the adequacy of capital, including:

(a) Risks captured under Pillar 1 (i.e. credit risk, market risk and operational risk);

(b) Risks considered but not fully captured under Pillar 1 (e.g. credit concentrationrisk);

(c) Risks that are not taken into account by Pillar 1 (e.g. liquidity risk, interest raterisk in the banking book, technology and cyber risk, reputational risk andstrategic risk) ; and

(d) Risks and external factors outside the direct control of the bank, includingchanges in regulations, accounting rules and the economic environment (e.g.business cycle effects).

32. A bank should ensure that senior management puts in place a risk management systemthat is robust and comprehensive, and be capable of capturing the nature and magnitudeof all material risks faced by the bank. The sophistication of the risk managementsystem should be proportionate to the risks that are present and the size and complexityof the bank.

33. A bank should aggregate multiple types of risks and assess how the aggregate risksimpact their capital level after taking into account the risk diversification effects. Itshould consider risks that do not appear to be significant in isolation, but whencombined with other risks could lead to material losses.

34. A bank should fully document the risk assessment process and should be able todemonstrate to the AMCM that all material risks have been considered and accountedfor in its ICAAP. Specific requirements of the ICAAP for main risk categories havebeen set out in Annex 2 for further reference.

35. For each material risk identified in its ICAAP, a bank should incorporate the followinginto its risk assessment and management process:

(a) A bank should conduct detailed analysis to determine the effectiveness andappropriateness of risk management techniques in controlling the risksidentified;

Page 7 of 26

(b) A bank should ensure that the risk assessments are consistent and objective;

(c) A bank should incorporate changes in its risk profile into its risk assessmentson a timely basis;

(d) A bank should conduct both quantitative and qualitative methods of riskassessment; and

(e) A bank should ensure the integrity of data used in its risk measurement processand such data is verifiable.

36. A bank should perform regular reviews of its ICAAP to ensure that all the risksidentified continue to be relevant and accounted for, and that new risks are incorporatedinto the ICAAP on a timely basis. A bank is also expected to make adjustments to itsICAAP in light of changes in its operating profile or environment.

Stress Testing

37. A bank should adopt stress testing as one of the most important risk assessment toolsin its ICAAP, and perform it on a regular basis, in order to provide a complementaryrisk perspective and evaluate additional capital needs.

38. The stress tests conducted by a bank should be rigorous and forward-looking and shouldcover a period of at least three years following the last financial year for capital planningas indicated in paragraph 30. The assumptions and figures used in the stress tests shouldbe appropriate and reasonable for the above-mentioned planning horizon. Theframework, methodology and extent of the stress tests should be commensurate withthe bank’s nature, size and complexity of its business operation and risk profile.

39. A bank should develop its own scenarios to stress test all its material portfolios andmaterial risks identified according to its ICAAP, and should be able to explain to theAMCM its reasons for the choice of stress testing scenarios.

40. A bank should duly assess the results of stress tests, always taking into account itsdetermined risk appetite and capacity limits. The results should be communicatedclearly and regularly to the board and senior management as it is expected that theresults will have a meaningful impact on strategic decisions.

41. The result of stress tests should be used to determine the capital buffer that a bankshould hold to enable it to withstand risks under stress conditions, adjust businessstrategies, set exposure limits and adjust controls. The result will form part of a bank’sICAAP report submitted to the AMCM.

Page 8 of 26

42. For more guidance on stress testing, a bank may refer to Annex 3of this guideline andrelevant publications issued by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS).

Monitoring and Reporting

43. A bank should establish adequate systems for monitoring and reporting risk exposuresand assessing how changes to its risk profile affect the need for capital. The board andsenior management of a bank should receive regular reports or updates on its risk profileand capital needs. These reports should enable senior management to:

(a) Evaluate the level and trend of material risks and their effect on capital levels;

(b) Evaluate the sensitivity and reasonableness of assumptions used in the capitalassessment and measurement system;

(c) Determine that the bank holds sufficient capital against the various risks;

(d) Determine that the bank is in compliance with the regulatory capital requirement(including Pillar 2 capital requirement and other capital buffers if any) set bythe AMCM; and

(e) Assess the future capital requirements based on the bank’s risk profile and makenecessary adjustments to the bank’s strategic plan accordingly.

44. A bank should ensure that the reporting lines on the risk profile and capital position areclear, precise, well-defined, transparent, coherent and enforced.

Internal Control Review

45. A bank’s internal control structure is essential to its ICAAP. Effective control of thecapital assessment process includes an independent review and, where appropriate, theinvolvement of internal and external audits.

46. A bank should ensure that the systems for assessing the risks to which it is exposed andfor relating those risks to the capital level of the bank are reviewed independently bypersons other than those responsible for the design or implementation of the ICAAP.

47. A bank should ensure that the independent review team or person possesses thenecessary technical capabilities to perform the independent review in order to providean effective challenge to persons responsible for the design and implementation of theICAAP.

48. A bank should conduct periodic reviews of its risk management process to ensure itsintegrity, accuracy and reasonableness.

Page 9 of 26

49. The independent review performed on a bank’s risk management function should atleast cover the following areas:

(a) Appropriateness of its capital assessment process given the nature, scale andcomplexity of its activities;

(b) Identification of large exposures and risk concentrations;

(c) Accuracy and completeness of data inputs into the assessment process;

(d) Reasonableness and validity of scenarios used in the assessment process; and

(e) Stress testing and analysis of assumptions and inputs.

50. The outcomes of independent review should be promptly reported to the board andsenior management of a bank, with clear identification of any need for additional capital.A bank should make appropriate adjustments and updates according to the results ofthe independent review of its ICAAP policies, procedures and implementation.

51. A bank should have complete documentation covering its ICAAP (includingmethodologies, assumptions, policies and procedures, responsibilities, etc.) to enablethe AMCM and third-parties’ review and evaluation.

Determination of the Internal Capital Requirement under the ICAAP

52. To determine the internal capital requirement under the ICAAP, a bank should use theregulatory capital requirement under Pillar 1 as a floor and determine a capital add-onso as to cover risks not fully covered, or not captured under Pillar 1 (refer to paragraphs31 (b)-(d)). The additional capital buffer required to meet regulatory capitalrequirement set by the AMCM and the management buffer set by the bank (if any)should also be considered and included in the bank’s overall internal capitalrequirement. In addition, it should also determine the composition of its requiredinternal capital.

53. In assessing the internal capital requirement for risks that are not captured or not fullycaptured under Pillar 1, a bank should explain in detail the assumptions applied andjustify the appropriateness of its methodology adopted given its risk level andsophistication of its operations.

54. The required internal capital should enable a bank to meet its regulatory capitalrequirement set by the AMCM in the event of a severe economic recession or of clearlyunfavourable business circumstances, and factor in the potential difficulties of raisingadditional capital under the stress conditions. Thus, regardless of the model adopted, abank should perform stress tests (including quantitative and qualitative) on eachindividual material risk to which it is exposed and make appropriate adjustment to the

Page 10 of 26

internal capital requirements determined for its planning horizon under normalconditions accordingly.

ICAAP Report

55. A bank subject to the capital adequacy requirement should submit its annual ICAAPreport to the AMCM not later than 30th April of each year, in respect of its ICAAPassessment based on the year-end figures of the last financial year. For a bank withsubsidiaries, the ICAAP report should be prepared on a solo and a consolidated basis,taking into account all material risks at the consolidated level.

56. While the AMCM will not rely on a bank’s own capital assessment in determining itsinternal capital requirement under the ICAAP, the AMCM may use informationgleaned from a bank’s ICAAP report to assess its inherent risk, quality of riskmanagement and capital needs. Whenever appropriate, the AMCM may seek otheradditional information from the bank on a case-by-case basis.

57. To enhance the comparability of respective ICAAPs across different banks with similarrisk profiles and make the ICAAP and the SREP more efficient, a bank should prepareits ICAAP report using the standardised ICAAP report template according to therequirement of the AMCM and following the specific instructions provided with theICAAP report template.

58. The ICAAP report submitted should be approved by a bank’s board and signed off bysenior management confirming that the requirements of this Guideline in relation to theICAAP have been strictly followed and the information provided in this report or alongwith the report is accurate in all material respects. In addition, the ICAAP report shouldbe reviewed by a bank’s internal audit department, and where deemed necessary by theAMCM, the ICAAP report should also be reviewed by an external party. A copy of theinternal and/or external review report should be attached to the submission.

SECTION III – THE SREP

Overview of the SREP

59. The SREP is a set of procedures carried out by the AMCM to ensure a bank has in placea sound, effective and comprehensive ICAAP, with the main objective of ensuring thebank has sufficient capital to support its risk profile.

60. The basic components of the SREP are already embedded in the AMCM’s existingsupervisory framework which rests on two key elements including off-site reviews andon-site examinations. The implementation of the SREP in the context of this Guidelinewill be more of an elaboration and refinement process, rather than a radical change inexisting practices.

Page 11 of 26

61. The AMCM will adopt a proportionate approach to the SREP. The depth, frequencyand intensity of the SREP will take into account the nature, scale, complexity and riskprofile of each bank. Under normal circumstances, the AMCM will conduct a regular(i.e. annual) review and evaluation on a bank’s ICAAP.

62. The SREP of the AMCM will typically involve some combinations of:

(a) On-site examinations or inspections;

(b) Off-site reviews, including review of ICAAP report;

(c) Discussions with banks’ management;

(d) Reviews of audit work done focused on capital adequacy issues; and

(e) Periodic reporting by banks.

63. The AMCM will also assess a bank’s stress testing methodologies and results as partof the SREP, in order to evaluate and determine the need for the bank to hold adequatecapital buffers.

Key Principles

64. The AMCM will adhere to the following principles during its SREP:

(a) The SREP should apply to all banks that are subject to the capital adequacyrequirements;

(b) The SREP should cover all activities of a bank;

(c) The SREP should cover all material risks as well as risk management andinternal control systems of a bank;

(d) The SREP will review and evaluate a bank’s ICAAP;

(e) The SREP will review and assess a bank’s compliance with all capital adequacyrequirements;

(f) The SREP should identify existing or potential problems and key risks faced bya bank and deficiencies in its risk management and control frameworks;

(g) The SREP should enable the AMCM to identify any prudential measures orother supervisory actions required;

Page 12 of 26

(h) The result of the SREP will be communicated to a bank at the appropriate leveltogether with any action that is required of the bank and any significant actionplanned by the AMCM.

(i) The SREP should be formally reviewed at least on an annual basis to ensure thatit is up-to-date and remains accurate.

Review and Evaluation of the ICAAP

65. The AMCM will review and assess the ICAAP to ensure that its methodology andassumptions are sound and that the following areas are addressed:

(a) Adequacy of risk assessment;

(b) Capital adequacy;

(c) Control environment; and

(d) Compliance with capital requirements.

66. The AMCM will assess the degree to which internal targets and processes incorporatethe full range of material risks faced by a bank. Moreover, the AMCM will assess theadequacy of risk measures and their use in determining capital adequacy, evaluatingand controlling risks, setting limits and evaluating performance.

67. The AMCM will ensure that a bank’s target levels of capital and their composition areappropriate to the nature and scale of the bank’s operations, and that the levels of capitalare properly monitored and reviewed by senior management. The AMCM will alsoassess the extent to which the bank’s ICAAP sets out its capital plans should anunexpected event occur under a range of external conditions and scenarios.

68. The AMCM will examine the quality of a bank’s management information reportingand systems, as well as management’s track record in responding to emerging orchanging risks. The AMCM will assess whether the determination of capital adequacyis linked to the bank’s overall risk profile and the effectiveness of its risk managementprocess.

69. The AMCM will ensure a bank’s internal methodologies, which provide integrity to itsreported capital measures such as risk mitigation, risk management standards anddisclosure, meet minimum supervisory requirements.

70. A bank must be able to explain and demonstrate to the satisfaction of the AMCM:

(a) How its ICAAP meets supervisory requirements;

Page 13 of 26

(b) How it defines, categorises and measures its material risks;

(c) How the internal capital targets are chosen and how they relate to the overallrisk profile and current operating environment of the bank; and

(d) How these targets are consistent with the present and future business needs ofthe bank.

Determination of Total Capital Requirement under the SREP

71. The AMCM will carry out an overall assessment of a bank’s risk profile and the capitalneeds derived from its risk profile, in order to determine the bank’s total capitalrequirement under the SREP.

72. The total capital requirement set by the AMCM is made up of the regulatory capitalrequirement under Pillar 1 plus a capital add-on as required by Pillar 2 to address overallrisks and uncertainties faced by a bank, including a capital buffer required to coverstress testing, as well as a supervisory capital add-on imposed by the AMCM whenconsidered necessary under the SREP.

Dialogue with Banks

73. Under the SREP, the AMCM will enter into an active dialogue with a bank for thefollowing purposes:

(a) To obtain a deeper understanding of the bank’s overall risk profile and its riskcontrol system;

(b) To understand the approach of the bank towards the risks not fully covered ornot captured by Pillar 1 and the amount of capital allocated to them;

(c) To evaluate the extent of reliance on the ICAAP in the AMCM’s assessment ofthe capital adequacy of the bank;

(d) To exchange information on the key findings of the SREP and anyrecommendations; and

(e) To ensure follow-up on the implementation of any prudential measures that maybe decided by the AMCM.

74. This dialogue will take place with the management, the compliance officer and theofficers in charge of risk measuring and monitoring or any person at an appropriatelevel designated by a bank.

Page 14 of 26

Supervisory Response

75. After the completion of the SREP, the AMCM will consider whether the existingregulatory capital requirement remains appropriate for a bank or whether it needs to bechanged in the light of the results and findings of the SREP.

76. The AMCM will discuss with a bank the results of its assessment, including any areasof concern, which may lead to an increase in its regulatory capital requirement. TheAMCM will explain the factors that have led to this assessment and recommend actionswhich the bank should take to address the concerns.

77. When there is a proposed increase in the regulatory capital requirement, a bank will beconsulted before a final decision is taken.

78. The AMCM also has the power to take a range of actions including but not limited tothe following:

(a) Intensifying the monitoring of a bank;

(b) Restricting current activities;

(c) Prohibiting new activities or acquisitions;

(d) Restricting or prohibiting the payment of dividends;

(e) Requiring a bank to prepare and implement a satisfactory capital adequacyrestoration plan; and

(f) Requiring a bank to raise additional capital.

79. The AMCM has the discretion to use the tools best suited to the circumstances of abank and its operating environment.

80. The AMCM will monitor the progress made by a bank in implementing the remedialactions.

~ End~

Page 15 of 26

Annex 1 – Key Aspects for the ICAAP Implementation

1. Key Steps in the ICAAP Implementation

The AMCM, in terms of the ICAAP, as part of the SREP would expect the following distinctfour steps to be included in the implementation process for a bank.

Step 1- Definition of Internal Requirement

A bank should first identify the range of applicable supervisory requirements, especially inrespect of this Guideline. The general requirements should then be deployed and specified toreflect the special characteristics of the bank. During the ICAAP, all material risks should beidentified, which will form the starting point for the definition of the bank’s risk profile. Afterthe definition of the current risk profile of the bank, the required state should be defined interms of capital, governance and internal control system.

Step 2- Gap Analysis

Once the internal requirement has been defined, a bank should analyse those requirementswhich are currently not or not completely fulfilled. In this process, the bank should review thecurrent state of methods, processes and structure in its internal risk management system. Thecomparison of the required or target state to the actual state can help identify the gaps whichwill need to be bridged during implementation. The result of this exercise should bedocumented in detail in the ICAAP report.

Step 3- Implementation Planning

During the planning, the required measures should first be prioritized so that implementationresources can be allocated appropriately. The individual measures should then be assigned tothe organizational unit which will perform them. Finally, due dates and responsibilities shouldbe specified for each process.

Step 4- Implementation

A bank should include the elaboration or adaption of methodological plans in the first phase ofimplementation. Next, the bank can execute actions which are targeted at establishingcompliance with requirements set by the ICAAP. Then the process-related aspects andresponsibilities within the ICAAP should be defined and documented (e.g. linking up risks andrequired capital, limit monitoring, taking actions). The ICAAP should be integrated in thebank’s strategic and operational control mechanisms (e.g. annual strategic planning andbudgeting). Furthermore, the ICAAP should also be an integral part of the bank’s governanceand decision-making processes.

Page 16 of 26

2. ICAAP Building Blocks

A bank may follow the phased approach presented below as a checklist or a quick referenceguide for a complete ICAAP implementation, together with related requirements included inthis Guideline.

•Engage the board and senior management;•Establish an ICAAP Steering Committee and an ICAAPPlan and Design the ICAAPImplementation Team;•Assign the responsibility for the implementation and supervision.

•Assess group structure and business model/products/services;Assess Internal and External Business•Review shareholding structure;Environment•Assess current political, economic and business environment.

•Assess organizational structure and governance frameworkincludingthe responsibilities of the board and senior management;Assess Internal Governance•Evaluate risk management, internal control and review functions,Framework, Risk Management including related policies and procedures;System and Internal Control System •Assess compliance level with regulatory requirements andconformance with internal and/or external auditor's recommendationsif any.

•Perform risk assessment for risks covered under Pillar 1, risks notfully covered and not covered under Pillar 1.Perfom Risk Assessment •Determine the internal capital requirement for each material risk for aperiod covering the last financial year and at least three yearsfollowing the last financial year.

•Assess and quantify risks using forward-looking stress testingscenarios through appropriate methodologies including sensitivityConduct Stress Testing analysis, scenario analysis and reverse stress testing;•Evaluate impact on profitability and capital adequacy for at leastthree years following the last financial year.

•Assess internal capital adequacy in respect of the last financial year;•Establish a business plan and projected financial figures for at leastthree years following the last financial year;Assess Capital Adequacy and •Prepare a capital plan for at least three years following the lastfinancial year based on the above financial projections and theEstablish Capital Plans results of stress tests, including the determination of internal capitalneeds under the ICAAP;•Decide the additional capital and/or controls allocated for materialrisks identified.

•Define next steps to mitigate material risks identified, strengtheninternal control system and assign responsibility for implementation;•Prepare and approve the annual ICAAP report as at the end of the lastNext Steps and ICAAP Reportfinancial year;•SubmittheannualICAAPreporttotheAMCMnotlaterthan30thApril of each year following the last financial year.

Page 17 of 26

Annex 2 - Specific Requirements of ICAAP for Main Risk Categories

1. As mentioned in paragraph 34 of this Guideline, this Annex sets out additional detailson the expectations of the AMCM with regard to the ICAAP of a bank. While thisAnnex is intended to help a bank in assessing the comprehensiveness and rigor of itsICAAP, it should not be construed as an exhaustive compliance checklist. A bankshould refer to the Pillar 2 principles and guidance as well as relevant risk managementpublications issued by the Basel Committee and the AMCM. The following main riskcategories are covered in this Annex:

(a) Credit risk;

(b) Market risk;

(c) Operational risk;

(d) Credit concentration risk;

(e) Liquidity risk;

(f) Interest rate risk in the banking book (IRRBB);

(g) Technology and cyber risk;

(h) Reputational risk;

(i) Strategic risk; and

(j) Other material risks.

Credit Risk

2. Credit risk is most simply defined as the potential that a borrower or counterparty of abank will fail to meet its obligations in accordance with agreed terms. Credit risk hastwo dimensions: the possibility of default by the counterparty on a bank’s creditexposure and the amount of loss that a bank may suffer when the default occurs.

3. Sources of credit risk exist throughout the activities of a bank in the banking book andtrading book, and both on and off the balance sheet. In addition to loans, a bank facescredit risk from trade finance and acceptances, interbank transactions, commitmentsand guarantees, financial derivative contracts, bond and equity holdings and settlementof transactions.

4. A bank should design its credit risk management process to identify and manage thecredit risk inherent in the products it offers and the activities in which it engages.

Page 18 of 26

5. A bank should conduct periodic stress tests for credit risk and review the results of thosetests to identify and respond to potential changes in market conditions that couldadversely impact the bank’s performance.

6. A bank should employ standardised approach to assess the credit risk involved inexposures to individual borrowers or counterparties as well as at the portfolio level. Ata minimum, it should comply with the requirements as instructed in “Credit Risk ReturnCompletion Instructions” contained in Circular no.028/B/2015-DSB/AMCM issued bythe AMCM.

Market Risk

7. Market risk is the risk of losses in on and off balance sheet positions arising frommovements in market prices, such as equity prices, interest rates, foreign exchange ratesand commodity prices. A bank should have methodologies that enable it to assess andactively manage the market risk wherever it arises.

8. A bank should design its market risk management process to properly measure thematerial risk in the instruments it trades as well as the trading strategy it pursues.

9. A bank should conduct periodic stress tests for market risk and demonstrate that it hasenough capital to not only meet the minimum capital requirement but also to withstanda range of severe but plausible market shocks. The market shocks applied in the stresstests should reflect the nature of portfolios and the time it would take to hedge out ormanage risks under severe market conditions.

10. A bank should employ standardised approach to assess its market risk. At a minimum,it should comply with the requirements as instructed in “Market Risk ReturnCompletion Instructions” contained in Circular no.028/B/2015-DSB/AMCM issued bythe AMCM.

Operational risk

11. Operational risk arises from potential problems due to inadequate or failed internalprocesses, people and systems, or from external events. It includes legal risk, butexcludes strategic and reputational risk. Operational risk is inherent in all bankingproducts, activities, processes and systems, and the effective management ofoperational risk is a fundamental element of a bank’s risk management programme. Thefailure to properly manage operational risk can result in misstatement of a bank’srisk/return profile and expose the bank to significant losses.

12. A bank should have an operational risk management framework that is responsible formanaging operational risk and evaluating the adequacy of capital given this framework.The framework should cover the bank’s appetite and tolerance for operational risk, as

Page 19 of 26

specified through the policies for managing this risk, including the extent and mannerin which operational risk is transferred outside the bank. The framework shouldconsider risk factors that may not have been adequately assessed under the Pillar 1process.

13. A bank should set out clearly the policies and procedures for the identification,assessment, monitoring, and control and mitigation of operational risk inherent in allmaterial products, activities, processes and systems, in its operational risk managementframework. Any deviation from the established policies should be reported to the boardor senior management, as appropriate.

14. A bank should keep track of relevant losses by business line and create incentives forthe improvement of operational risk. There should be regular reporting of operationalrisk losses throughout the bank.

15. A bank should employ basic indicator approach to assess operational risk. At aminimum, it should comply with the requirements as instructed in “Operational RiskReturn Completion Instructions” contained in Circular no.028/B/2015-DSB/AMCMissued by the AMCM.

Credit Concentration Risk

16. A risk concentration is any single exposure or group of exposures with the potential toproduce losses large enough (relative to a bank’s capital, total assets, or overall risklevel) to threaten a bank’s health or ability to maintain its core operations. As lendingis the primary activity of most banks, credit risk concentrations are often the mostmaterial risk concentrations within a bank.

17. Credit risk concentrations, by their nature, are based on common or correlated riskfactors, which, in times of stress, have an adverse effect on the creditworthiness of eachof the individual counterparty making up the concentration. Concentration risk arisesin both direct exposures to obligors and may also occur through exposures to protectionproviders. The types of credit concentration mainly include single name, sectoral, andgeographic concentration.

18. A bank should have in place effective internal policy, system and control to identify,measure, monitor, and control their credit risk concentrations. It should explicitlyconsider the extent of its credit risk concentrations in its assessment of capital adequacyunder Pillar 2. The related policy should cover the different forms of credit riskconcentrations to which a bank may be exposed.

19. A bank’s framework for managing credit risk concentrations should be clearlydocumented and should include a definition of the credit risk concentrations relevant tothe bank and how these concentrations and their corresponding limits are calculated.Limits should be defined in relation to a bank’s capital, total assets or, where adequate

Page 20 of 26

measures exist, its over risk level. In order to facilitate peer comparison and supervisoryjudgment, a bank should also assess their credit concentration risk by using theHerfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) besides its other own methodologies.

20. A bank should conduct periodic stress tests for credit concentration risk and take intoaccount changes in the business environment that may occur and that would lead to thematerialisation of the concentration risk.

21. A bank should ensure that its internal policies, systems and controls for creditconcentration risk management are in compliance with Chapter VII “Prudential ruleson exposure of banks” of the FSAM.

Liquidity Risk

22. Liquidity risk is the risk that a bank will have difficulties in paying its financialliabilities. This may be caused by funding liquidity risk or market liquidity risk.Funding liquidity risk is the risk that a bank will not be able to meet efficiently bothexpected and unexpected current and future cash flow and collateral needs withoutaffecting either daily operations or the financial condition of the bank. Market liquidityrisk is the risk that a bank cannot easily offset or eliminate a position at the market pricebecause of inadequate market depth or market disruption.

23. A bank should adopt sound liquidity risk management practices that are commensuratewith its size and sophistication, and with the risk and complexity of its activities.

24. A bank should conduct periodic stress tests for liquidity risk and maintain sufficientliquidity to withstand a range of stress events and to weather prolonged periods offinancial market stress and illiquidity.

25. A bank should consider the relationship between liquidity and capital since liquidityrisk can impact capital adequacy which, in turn, can aggravate the bank’s liquidityprofile. It should evaluate its capital adequacy taking into account its liquidity profileand the liquidity of the markets in which it operates.

26. At a minimum, a banks should refer to “Guideline on Management of Liquidity Risk”(Circular no.003/B/2011-DSB/AMCM) issued by the AMCM for the detailedrequirements on liquidity risk management.

Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book (IRRBB)

27. Interest rate risk in the banking book (IRRBB) refers to the current or prospective riskto a bank’s capital and earnings arising from adverse movements in interest rates thataffect the bank’s banking book positions.

Page 21 of 26

28. As interest income constitutes a significant portion of the total revenue of a bank, it isimportant for a bank to have in place a risk management framework to manage itsIRRBB associated with its business activities and ensure that it has sufficient capital tocover its IRRBB exposures. A bank with large regional exposures should also assessthe impact of interest rate risk on its operations in these countries. This is especiallypertinent in countries whose currencies are relatively less actively traded in theinternational financial markets.

29. A bank’s measurement systems and models used for IRRBB should be based onaccurate data and subject to appropriate documentation, testing and controls to giveassurance on the accuracy of calculations.

30. A bank should conduct periodic stress tests for IRRBB to measure its vulnerability toloss under stressful market conditions, including the breakdown of key assumptions. Itshould demonstrate that it has enough capital to not only meet the minimum capitalrequirement but also to withstand a range of severe but plausible market shocks.

31. Measurement outcomes of IRRBB and hedging strategies should be reported to seniormanagement or its delegates on a regular basis, at relevant levels of aggregation.

32. Information on the level of IRRBB exposure and practices for measuring andcontrolling IRRBB should be disclosed to the public on a regular basis.

33. At a minimum, a bank should refer to “Guideline on Management of Interest Rate Risk”(Circular no.051/B/2008-DSB/AMCM) issued by the AMCM for the detailedrequirements on the management of IRRBB.

Technology and Cyber Risk

34. Technology and cyber risk is becoming more prominent to the operations of a bank.Technology risk refers to risks emanating from the use of information technology (IT)and the Internet. These risks arise from failures or breaches of IT systems, applications,platforms or infrastructure, which could result in financial loss, disruptions in financialservices or operations, or reputational harm to a bank. Cyber risk is a subset oftechnology risk, which might compromise a bank’s cyber security. This couldmaterialize in a variety of ways, such as deliberate and unauthorized breaches ofsecurity to gain access to information systems, unintentional or accidental breaches ofsecurity and operational IT risks due to factors such as poor system integrity.

35. A bank should ensure that the technology and cyber risk management is an integral partof the bank’s enterprise risk management framework, with appropriate written policiesand procedures. It should include the following:

(a) Clear definition of technology and cyber risk;

Page 22 of 26

(b) Clear responsibilities assigned for the management of technology and cyber riskat different levels and across functions, with appropriate governance andreporting arrangements;

(c) The identification of technology and cyber risk to which the bank is exposed,including risks from the adoption of new or emerging technology;

(d) Risk classification of all information assets or systems based on its criticality;

(e) Risk measurement and assessment approaches and methodologies;

(f) Risk controls and mitigations; and

(g) Continuous monitoring to timely detect and address any material risks.

36. A bank should effectively implement enterprise-wide independent technology andcyber risk management function and ensure its information assets and technologies areadequately protected. It includes advising on critical technology projects and ensuringcritical issues that may have an impact on the bank’s risk tolerance are adequatelydeliberated or escalated in a timely manner, as well as providing independent views tothe board and senior management on third party assessments, where necessary.

37. A bank should establish appropriate governance requirements commensurate with therisk and complexity of technology projects undertaken. This should include projectoversight roles and responsibilities, authority and reporting structures, and riskassessments throughout the project life cycle.

38. A bank should ensure that there is an enterprise-wide focus on effective managementof cyber risk and establish related management framework, including managing itscyber resilience objectives and risk tolerance, with due regard to the evolving cyberthreat environment. At a minimum, it should refer to “Guideline on Cyber Resilience”(Circular no.016/B/2019-DSB/AMCM) issued by the AMCM for the detailedrequirements on the management of cyber risk.

Reputational Risk

39. Reputational risk refers to the risk that a bank’s reputation is damaged by one or morethan one reputation event, as reflected from negative publicity about the bank’s businesspractices, conduct or financial condition. Such negative publicity, whether true or not,may impair public confidence in the bank, result in costly litigation, or lead to a declinein its customer base, business or revenue.

40. A bank should have appropriate policies in place to identify sources of reputational riskand carry out regular analysis on the reputational risk to which it is exposed.

Page 23 of 26

41. Once a bank identifies potential exposures arising from reputational concerns, it shouldmeasure the amount of support it might have to provide or losses it might experienceunder adverse market conditions. In particular, in order to avoid reputational damagesand to maintain market confidence, a bank should develop methodologies to measureas precisely as possible the effect of reputational risk in terms of other risk types (e.g.credit, liquidity, market or operational risk) to which it may be exposed.

42. A bank should develop appropriate contingency plans based on the risk assessmentresult. When necessary and feasible, testing on the contingency plans should beconducted.

Strategic Risk

43. Strategic risk is the possibility of occurrence of adverse effects on a bank’s financialresult and capital due to the absence of appropriate policies and strategies, theirinadequate implementation, as well as changes in the environment where the bankoperates or absence of appropriate response of the bank to those changes.

44. A bank should develop appropriate policies and processes that allow for independentreviews of its strategies for identification and management of strategic risk likely tohave a material impact on the bank’s ability to achieve its mission and objectives.

45. A bank should adequately evaluate the negative impact of strategic risk that might haveon its capital, and allocate appropriate capital relative to the level of its strategic risk ifany.

Other Material Risks

46. A bank should also consider whether there are any other risks to which it is materiallyexposed and the impact they may have on overall capital adequacy.

Page 24 of 26

Annex 3 - Guidance on Stress Testing

1. This Annex provides guidance on stress testing methodologies including the stressscenarios commonly used for the ICAAP.

2. Stress testing is not a one-size-fits-all approach and requires the use of various types ofmethodologies. The range of methodologies acceptable for a bank greatly depends onnature, size and complexity of its business operations and risk profile. With a view tothe principle of proportionality, however, the AMCM requires that the applied stresstesting methodology should be sufficiently sophisticated for all material risks to whicha bank is exposed.

3. The stress tests applied under the framework of the ICAAP in business and regulatorypractice usually relate to the following three main methods (i.e. sensitivity analysis,scenario analysis and reverse stress test). These may be used either separately or inconjunction with each other.

(1)Sensitivity analysis. It is usually based on a less complex methodology andillustrates how a bank’s position would change, in case a single relevant risk factoris modified, but all other circumstances remain unchanged. It can be used as asimple technique for assessing the impact of a change in risks when a quickresponse or when more frequent results are needed.

(2)Scenario analysis. It assumes the simultaneous change of several risk factors andquantify their combined impact on a bank’s position, suitably taking intoconsideration the secondary and delayed effects. It can also be based onhypothetical and historic scenarios. This method takes into consideration therelationship among risk factors and thereby enables the capturing of a bank’s risksin an integrated approach.

(3)Reverse stress test. It requires a bank to assess scenarios and circumstances thatwould render its business model unviable, thereby identifying potential businessvulnerabilities. It starts from a known stress test outcome (such as breachingregulatory capital ratios, illiquidity or insolvency) and then works backward toidentify the causes and consequences that could lead to such an outcome. It is seenas one of the risk management tools complementing general stress testingtechniques and can help senior management in considering the range of scenariosthat impact on a bank’s viability or solvency.

4. A bank should identify its main risk factors that require stress testing according to itsICAAP and develop its own scenarios to cover all its major risks and material portfolios.For example, it may include the following stress scenarios listed below for capitalplanning. This is an indicative and not exhaustive sample of stress scenarios that theAMCM would consider as worth of mention in the ICAAP Report.

Page 25 of 26

(1)Credit Risk

- A drop in mortgaged collateral value;- An increase in non-performing loans (NPLs) due to downgrade of loans, etc.

(2)Market Risk

- A decline in market value of financial instruments held due to adverse changes inmarket prices (e.g. equity prices, interest rates, foreign exchange rates andcommodity prices), etc.

(3)Credit Concentration Risk

- Default by major non-bank borrowers/ group of borrowers;- Default in exposures of major sectors;- Default in major Mainland-related exposures, etc.

(4)Liquidity Risk

- A fall in liquid liabilities (i.e. deposits, interbank borrowing, etc.), etc.

(5)Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book (IRRBB)

- A parallel interest rate shock, etc.

Page 26 of 26

官方文件下載

以上連結直接指向 AMCM 官方伺服器,本站不託管任何官方文件。